In the past, I’ve written a post comparing the major hotel loyalty programs, sharing what I view as the pros and cons of each. There are various factors to consider, ranging from a hotel group’s global footprint, to elite recognition, to the points earning structure.

For many people, the single most valuable perk of hotel elite status is upgrades to suites. In this post, I want to compare the suite upgrade policies of the “big four” hotel loyalty programs, to determine which is best.

Comparing hotel loyalty program suite upgrade policies

Who doesn’t love a suite upgrade? I mean, it might not be necessary on a one night stay at an airport hotel when you’re traveling alone, but it sure comes in handy when you’re traveling with family on a special vacation.

Fortunately hotel loyalty programs may offer suite upgrades to their most loyal members. In this post, I’ll compare the suite upgrade policies of the four all-around most lucrative hotel loyalty programs — Hilton Honors, IHG One Rewards, Marriott Bonvoy, and World of Hyatt.

Let’s look at the complimentary upgrade policies of each program, and then we’ll also look at opportunities available through each program for securing suite upgrades in advance.

Below is my ranking of hotel loyalty program suite upgrade benefits, starting with the best.

World of Hyatt

World of Hyatt Globalist status sets the standard for suite upgrade policies, both when it comes to space available upgrades, as well as the ability to confirm upgrades in advance.

Hyatt Globalist members receive unlimited space available suite upgrades at check-in, subject to availability. If a standard suite is available, you should receive an upgrade to this as a Globalist member (of course there could be more Globalist members than suites available, but the idea is that some Globalist members should get the upgrade).

Furthermore, with the World of Hyatt Milestone Rewards program, Globalist members who rack up 60 elite nights in a year can earn five confirmed suite upgrade awards, each of which can be used to confirm an upgrade to a standard suite at the time of booking for up to seven nights, with no capacity controls — as long as a standard suite is available for sale, you can confirm it.

You can earn further suite upgrade awards for over qualifying for status (you can choose a suite upgrade award with every 10 elite nights earned, from 70 all the way to 150 elite nights), or if you’re a lifetime Globalist member. Note that even elite nights earned with credit cards count toward these thresholds.

You can’t beat the combination of unlimited suite upgrades subject to availability, plus easy to earn confirmable suite upgrades that can be used at the time of booking.

Marriott Bonvoy

Marriott Bonvoy Platinum, Titanium, and Ambassador status, offers a fairly well-rounded suite upgrade benefit, though it’s not as good as with World of Hyatt on all fronts.

Marriott Platinum members and above receive upgrades at check-in, subject to availability. The catch is that the language for this benefit changed some time back. It used to be that elite members were promised the best available room up to a standard suite, while now the terms simply state that upgrades may be to suites, rooms with desirable views, rooms on high floors, corner rooms, etc.

So that means Marriott properties aren’t under any obligation to upgrade members to suites, even if they are available. That being said, many properties will still do so.

It’s worth noting that with the Marriott Bonvoy Choice Benefits program, members can select further benefits when passing 50 or 75 elite nights in a year (even elite nights earned with credit cards count toward this). At each threshold you can select five nightly upgrade awards, each of which can be used to confirm a suite upgrade starting three to five days before arrival (depending on the brand).

Ultimately I get quite a bit of value from these, but they have limitations — there are capacity controls on these, each is only valid for one night, and only being able to confirm an upgrade at most three to five days in advance doesn’t give you much certainty with travel planning.

So I don’t think Marriott is quite in Hyatt’s league, both when it comes to the ability to confirm upgrades, and when it comes to space available upgrades at check-in. However, the program is still pretty well-rounded, all things considered, especially with how easy it is to earn status, and to unlock the Choice Benefits perks.

IHG One Rewards

IHG One Rewards Diamond members receive room upgrades subject to availability, and these upgrades may include standard suites. However, upgrades are offered at the hotel’s discretion, meaning that a hotel doesn’t have to make a suite available for an upgrade, even if it’s empty.

While the space available suite upgrade offering is weak, IHG has an impressive confirmed suite upgrade option. With the IHG One Rewards Milestone Rewards program, members can earn up to three confirmed suite upgrades per year (which would require earning 70 elite nights).

Each confirmed suite upgrade can be used to confirm a suite upgrade between one day and 14 days prior to arrival, for a stay of up to five nights. These can be used on either cash stays or award stays.

While IHG’s space available upgrade benefit isn’t too exciting, at least the confirmed upgrade perk is a great opportunity. On the surface I’d say the suite upgrade perk is better than with Marriott, but the catch is that earning these Milestone Rewards perks is more complicated than with Marriott, especially for someone who has access to US credit cards.

Hilton Honors

As much as I’ve become a big fan of Hilton Honors in general, the program’s suite upgrade benefit is the weakest of the “big four.” Not only is the space available suite upgrade benefit not particularly strong, but Hilton only offers very limited opportunities for confirmed suite upgrades in advance.

Hilton Diamond elite members receive room upgrades subject to availability, and these upgrades may include standard suites. However, upgrades are offered at the hotel’s discretion, meaning that a hotel doesn’t have to make a suite available for an upgrade, even if it’s empty.

Furthermore, at least technically, Hilton Honors elite members don’t receive any upgrades at nine brands, including Embassy Suites, Hampton by Hilton, Hilton Garden Inn, Hilton Grand Vacations, Homewood Suites by Hilton, Home2 Suites by Hilton, Motto by Hilton, Spark by Hilton, and Tru by Hilton. However, in practice you may still find that elite members often get upgrades at these properties.

The same space available upgrade policy applies for the new Hilton Diamond Reserve tier, which requires 80 nights or 40 stays in a year, plus $18,000 in eligible spending.

Now, the good news is that Hilton finally has a confirmed upgrade perk, in the form of Diamond Reserve members receiving a single confirmable upgrade reward every year, valid at the time of booking for a stay of up to seven nights. While some benefit is better than none, it’s hard to get too excited about that, in my opinion.

An important suite upgrade reality check…

As anyone with hotel elite status can attest to, just because you’re entitled to a suite upgrade subject to availability doesn’t mean you’re going to get one:

• Even when hotels are fully playing by the rules, there will often be more elite members eligible for suite upgrades than available suites (just as airlines offer elite members complimentary upgrades, but that doesn’t mean there will be seats available)
• That doesn’t factor in that lots of hotels don’t play by the rules, and will do everything they can to avoid providing a suite upgrade; this comes down to the fact that most hotels are individually owned, and only have a management or franchise agreement with the major hotel group

As is the case with many aspects of elite recognition, I generally find that the further you get from the United States, the better elite recognition is. Furthermore, I find that being a repeat guest helps with getting priority for upgrades, and I also have better luck with upgrades on short stays than long stays.

With that in mind, what has my experience been with the major hotel groups when it comes to space available suite upgrades (while noting that there’s still huge variability with each group, given that hotels are individually owned)?

• I find that Hyatts are best about trying to provide complimentary suite upgrades when available, and I tend to get them pretty regularly, especially outside the United States
• With Marriott I only very rarely get proactive suite upgrades within the United States; there’s tons of competition for upgrades, and I find that I have the best luck internationally, and also when using nightly upgrade awards
• With Hilton I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a suite upgrade within the United States, while I get them fairly regularly abroad; I’d say that in Asia and the Middle East my suite upgrade percentage is roughly the same with Marriott and Hilton
• I unfortunately don’t have much firsthand experience with IHG’s top tier status, though the data points I’ve seen so far suggest that most IHG properties aren’t very good about space available suite upgrades

Anyway, that’s just my experience. I also can’t emphasize enough that especially in major cities or markets, it’s common that there could be dozens of people with a particular elite tier checking in on a specific day, and it can be hard to make everyone happy.

Bottom line

Suite upgrades are one of the best perks of hotel elite status, though not all suite upgrade policies are created equal. First you have the difference of how hotel loyalty programs offer space available upgrades — some offer suite upgrades subject to availability, while others offer them at the hotel’s discretion. Then you have some hotels that offer confirmed suite upgrades, but even those policies differ significantly between hotel groups.

When it comes to suite upgrades, personally I think World of Hyatt wins by a long shot. That’s both thanks to promising suite upgrades subject to availability, and also thanks to the generous confirmed suite upgrade awards.

Marriott Bonvoy, IHG One Rewards, and Hilton Honors, are all the same in terms of offering some sort of upgrade subject to availability, but giving the hotels lots of discretion. When it comes to confirmed upgrades, which program is best depends on how you qualify for status, and what your stay patterns look like.

What has your experience been with elite status suite upgrades at hotels? Which program is your favorite?